An article by the Troutman Sanders tobacco practice appears in the February issue of Smokeshop Magazine.  The article, titled “E-Cigs at the Forefront,” discusses the growing momentum for state-level regulation of tobacco product alternatives, with e-cigarettes attracting the most attention. The full text of the article can be found here.

Missouri, the last remaining state in which nonparticipating manufacturers (“NPMs”) can obtain allocable share releases from their escrow payments, has again introduced legislation to repeal the release mechanism. The bill, House Bill 1242, was introduced on January 8, 2014 and has been referred to and is pending before the House Budget Committee.

On February 12, 2014, congressmen from California, Iowa and Vermont sent a joint letter to the Attorneys General in those states, urging them to classify electronic cigarettes as cigarettes under the Master Settlement Agreement (“MSA”).  The MSA was adopted in 1998 and applies to cigarette and roll-your-own tobacco manufacturers.  In the letter, the lawmakers stated that classifying electronic cigarettes as cigarettes would be a “bold step” in the battle against tobacco use. 

As mentioned in a previous blog post, on September 11, 2013, a three-member federal arbitration panel settled the on-going dispute among three participating manufacturers (“PMs”) and 15 states involving the 2003 payment obligations under the Master Settlement Agreement (“MSA”).

New York is one of the states that the arbitrators ruled in favor of in denying the PMs a credit under the non-participating manufacturer (“NPM”) Adjustment.  The arbitration panel concluded that “the MSA’s first condition for application of the 2003 NPM Adjustment was satisfied: the PMS had suffered a ‘Market Share Loss’ for 2003.”  In particular, the independent auditor calculated approximately an 8 percent market-share shift from the PMs to the NPMs from 1997-2003.  New York (nor any of the other 14 states) disputed the auditor’s finding that the PMs suffered a market share loss in 2003.